The implementation of a judicial partition of property is a legal means of terminating co-ownership between two or more persons when they cannot agree on a voluntary distribution of property or inheritance. Judicial partition of property is conducted through a court proceeding that goes through several mandatory phases and requires serious preparation and evidence. In this article, we will examine the phases of the judicial partition of property process and what should be considered when filing a partition claim.
It is important to note that in the judicial partition of property proceedings, the court is obliged to ensure the participation of all co-owners as mandatory parties. If any co-owner is not constituted as a party, the case cannot proceed without their participation. This is because the law stipulates that when the partition is carried out without the participation of any of the co-heirs, it is entirely null and void.
When is a judicial partition necessary?
Judicial partition of property is applied in cases where the owners of a property or the heirs of certain assets fail to reach a voluntary agreement on its distribution among themselves. Such situations often arise in cases of inheritance, where several heirs own ideal shares of a particular property and cannot agree on its use or sale. In such scenarios, conducting a judicial partition of property is the only solution that can lead to the settlement of rights and the distribution of actual shares of ownership in favor of each co-owner.
Stages of the Judicial Partition of Property Process
The process of judicial partition of property goes through two main phases, regulated by the Civil Procedure Code.
2.1. First Phase: Admission of Partition
In the first phase of the judicial proceedings for conducting a judicial partition of property, the court examines and decides between which persons and for which properties the partition will be carried out, as well as what is the share of each by determining the shares of each co-owner. The proceedings for the admission of judicial partition of property include:
- Preparation and submission of a claim. To initiate the judicial partition of property proceedings, the interested party submits a claim to the district court at the location of the property or at the place of discovery of the inheritance, in which they state their request for partition and present the necessary documents (notarial deeds, certificates of heirs, etc.). It is important that the claim contains an accurate description of the property and the grounds for co-ownership.
- Verification of circumstances. The court examines the legal grounds for the ownership of each co-owner and determines the share of each, basing its legal conclusions on the documents and evidence presented.
- At this stage, each co-owner (heir) has the opportunity to object to the size of the shares of the other co-participants; against the inclusion of any of the properties in the inheritance mass or against the right of any of the other participants to participate in the partition at all.
- If necessary, at this stage of the partition proceedings, the court also considers and decides on preliminary (prejudicial) issues such as disputes over origin, adoptions, wills, and the authenticity of written evidence, as well as requests for the reduction of testamentary dispositions and donations.
Court Decision on Admission of Judicial Partition of Property. After examining the case and the issues mentioned above, the court issues a decision admitting the partition, ruling on the issues
2.2. Second Phase: Actual Distribution of the Property/Asset (Conducting Judicial Partition of Property).
After the court has issued the decision for the admission of the partition, the proceedings move to the second stage of the partition process, namely the phase of conducting the actual distribution of the property.
Before that, however, each co-participant may present claims for the so-called “accounts between them”. These include, for example, claims for income collected by one of the co-participants from the common property; for improvements made by one of the co-participants to the common property; regarding the payment of an inheritance debt by one of the co-participants, and similar. These “account” claims must be presented no later than at the first hearing of the case after the admission of the judicial partition of property.
Alongside this, the partition court begins procedural actions aimed at actually dividing the co-owned property. It is important to note here that the legislation provides for different methods of dividing co-owned property, depending on its nature and possibilities for division.
- Actual Distribution of Property: When the property subject to partition can be actually divided into parts that correspond to the size of each co-owner’s share, the court assigns the actual distribution to each of the parties. If it concerns real estate, a cadastral plan is drawn up, determining the shares and boundaries of the new properties.
- Monetary Equalization of Shares: When it is impossible to carry out an equitable actual distribution, the court may determine a monetary equalization for the difference in shares. For example, one co-owner may receive the entire property and compensate the other co-owners with monetary compensation that offsets the differences in the value of the shares.
- Public Sale: In cases where none of the above methods can be applied or the parties do not reach an agreement, the court may order a public sale of the property. After the sale, the proceeds are distributed among the co-owners according to their shares.
Key Issues and Features in Judicial Partition of Property
- Court Costs and Fees – The costs of the case may include court fees, fees for experts who evaluate the properties and propose a fair way to divide them; notarial fees and attorney fees. They are usually distributed among the co-owners according to their share in the co-ownership, unless the court rules otherwise.
- Appointment of an Expert – In most cases, an expert is needed to prepare an appraisal of the property, analyze the possibilities for actual division of a specific property or properties, and propose suitable options for the distribution of shares. The expert’s appraisal plays an important role in determining the value of the property and in decisions regarding monetary equalization.
- Appeal of the Court Decision – Each party has the right to appeal the court’s decision if they disagree with the issued distribution. In such a case, the case goes through a higher court instance, which may confirm, amend, or annul the initial decision. Both the decision on the admission of the partition and the subsequent decision on the actual conduct of the judicial partition of property are subject to appeal.
CONCLUSION
The judicial partition of property proceedings represents a series of legal actions that must be undertaken in a specific sequence to conclude the proceedings with the distribution of co-owned property and the termination of co-ownership.
Silvia Petkova Sole Law Firm has competent and experienced real estate lawyers, who can provide you with highly qualified legal assistance regarding the initiation and participation in judicial partition of property proceedings.
Legal consultations on-site at the office or by phone are provided only by prior appointment. If you wish to use our services, you can contact us at the following contacts:
Solo Law Firm “Silvia Petkova”
address: Sofia, “Tri Ushi” St. No. 2, floor 3
tel. 0885 47 77 57
email: office@petkovalegal.com
working hours: Monday to Friday from 10:00 to 18:00